Navigator Schools
Minutes
Board Meeting
Date and Time
Tuesday June 20, 2023 at 6:00 PM
Location
Gilroy Prep School, 277 IOOF Avenue, Gilroy, CA 95020
This meeting will be held in compliance with the Brown Act.
Members of the public who wish to access this board meeting online may do so via Zoom at https://zoom.us/join or via telephone by calling (669) 900-6833 or (669) 444-9171.
Zoom Meeting ID: 966 4749 3782
Zoom Passcode: 515777
Teleconference Locations / Ubicaciones de Teleconferencias
- Hayward Collegiate Charter School, 166 West Harder Road, Hayward, CA 94544
- Hollister Prep School, 881 Line Street, Hollister CA 95020
- Watsonville Prep School, 407 Main Street, Watsonville, CA 95076
- 169 Redding Road, Campbell, CA 95008
- 1065 Byers Street, Gilroy, CA 95020
- 3410 Moraga Boulevard, Lafayette, CA 94549
- 5357 Federation Court, San Jose, CA 95123
Members of the public attending online who wish to comment during the board meeting will use the online “raise hand” tool in Zoom when the chairperson elicits public comments. Members of the public planning to attend by phone are requested to confirm their intent to comment up to one hour prior to the meeting via e-mail.
Individual comments will be limited to three minutes. If an interpreter is needed, comments will be translated into English and the time limit shall be six minutes. At its discretion, the board may limit the total time allotted to public comments and set new time limits for individual comments. The board reserves the right to mute and remove a participant from the meeting if the participant unreasonably disrupts the meeting.
Requests for disability-related modifications or accommodations to participate in this public meeting should be submitted forty-eight hours prior to the meeting via e-mail. All efforts will be made for reasonable accommodations. The agenda and public documents will be modified upon request as required by Section 202 of the Americans with Disabilities Act.
Esta reunión se llevará a cabo de conformidad con la Brown Act.
Los miembros del público que deseen acceder a esta reunión del consejo pueden hacerlo en línea en https://zoom.us/join o por teléfono llamando al (669) 900-6833 o al (669) 444-9171.
Zoom Meeting ID: 966 4749 3782
Zoom Passcode: 515777
Los comentarios públicos se limitarán a tres minutos. Si se necesita un intérprete, los comentarios se traducirán al inglés y el límite de tiempo será de seis minutos. A su discreción, la mesa directiva puede limitar el tiempo total asignado a los comentarios del público y establecer nuevos límites de tiempo para los comentarios individuales. La mesa directiva se reserva el derecho de expulsar a un participante de la reunión si éste interrumpe injustificadamente la reunión.
Las solicitudes de modificaciones o adaptaciones relacionadas con una discapacidad para participar en esta reunión pública deberán presentarse cuarenta y ocho horas antes de la reunión por correo electrónico. Se hará todo lo posible por realizar adaptaciones razonables. El orden del día y los documentos públicos se modificarán si se solicita, tal y como exige el artículo 202 de la Ley de Estadounidenses con Discapacidades.
Directors Present
Chuck Daggs (remote), Claire Grissom (remote), Ian Connell, JP Anderson (remote), Jaime Quiroga (remote), John Flaherty, Shara Hegde (remote), Victor Paredes-Colonia (remote)
Directors Absent
Alfred Morikang
Guests Present
Kevin Sved (remote), Sean Martin
I. Opening Items
A.
Record Attendance and Guests
B.
Call the Meeting to Order
C.
Public Comments
D.
Board Chair’s Opening Remarks
The board chair commented on the scheduling of a new board meeting for July 25, 2023.
E.
Approve Minutes from Previous Regular Board Meeting
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Abstain
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
F.
CEO Report
Kevin Sved shared that this would be his last board meeting as Chief Executive Officer. He reflected upon the pleasures, milestones, and achievements experienced since the first board meeting he attended as CEO in 2016.
II. Finance
A.
Finance Committee Report
J.P. Anderson reviewed recent committee activities, and committee members discussed the impact and contributions of Victor Paredes-Colonia, the departing committee chair. Kevin Sved added details pertaining to the Financials document. J.P. Anderson thanked Ami Ortiz for working to prepare committee documents.
B.
Facilities Updates
Kevin Sved provided facilities information. Gilroy Unified School District approved a long-term lease for GPS connected to the completion of an upcoming construction project. Room modules have been pre-approved by a state architect. Kevin Sved discussed facilities development at Hayward Collegiate, including the city permitting process and related project management services provided by Public Charter School Development (PCSD).
C.
Approval of Project Management Agreement with Pacific Charter School Development
Kevin Sved provided a brief explanation of the project management agreement with PCSD.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
D.
Approval of Facilities Memorandum of Understanding with Gilroy Unified School District
Kevin Sved presented the terms of the Memorandum of Understanding with the district, the draft of which had been reviewed by the legal counsel of Navigator Schools. Shara Hegde congratulated Kevin and the team.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
E.
Approval of Contract with Underwood & Rosenblum, Inc
Kevin recommended approval of the contract, relating to topographical surveys and utilities.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
The board chair added additional comments pertaining to facilities development at GPS, emphasizing the success of obtaining a unanimous vote for project approval from the district board. Board members discussed the importance of preparing for similar votes in other districts. Chuck Daggs celebrated the financial terms of the MOU and thanked Kevin Sved for his leadership of the project.
F.
Local Indicators: Board Acceptance
Kevin Sved defined Local Indicators and thanked multiple team members for their respective contributions. The board decided to approve Local Indicators for all schools in a single vote.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
G.
2023-24 LCAP Approval: Gilroy Prep School
Ami Ortiz provided an overview of the Local Control and Accountability Plans (LCAP). She highlighted plan alignment to Navigator School Compass Points, and she noted that the LCAP for Hayward Collegiate is now in alignment with all of the other Navigator Schools. Kevin Sved discussed details relating to identifying annual metrics and goals. He also explained important connections to the CA School Dashboard. John Flaherty emphasized the value of sharing our concrete, positive, student results as documented in the LCAP with charter authorizers.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
H.
2023-24 LCAP Approval: Hayward Collegiate
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
I.
2023-24 LCAP Approval: Hollister Prep School
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
J.
2023-24 LCAP Approval: Watsonville Prep School
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
K.
2023-24 Proposed Navigator Schools Budget
Ami Ortiz provided an overview of the budget and the budgeting process, including state timelines, budget assumptions, expenditures, capital outlay, project fund balances, and next steps. Staff members provided additional details and answered clarifying questions regarding several topics, including SB 740 funding, competitive salaries, and cost of living.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
III. Governance
A.
Governance Committee Report
The committee chair reviewed recent committee activities. Members discussed future board composition, board recruitment priorities, potential board candidates, and the role and composition of the Support Corporation Board.
B.
Board Meeting Schedule for 2023-24
The board reviewed the proposed board meeting schedule, highlighting recent additions and modifications.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
C.
Resolution 2023-17: Recognition of Victor Paredes-Colonia for Board Service
Individual board members offered extensive praise and heartfelt thanks to departing board member and Finance Committee Chair Victor-Paredes Colonia. J.P. Anderson thanked Victor on behalf of his children — Navigator Students — in light of the fact that Victor had always placed the welfare and success of Navigator students, regardless of school, at the forefront of his many contributions to the board.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Abstain
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
D.
Election of Board Officers
The board chair explained updates to board officer positions. Kevin Sved reviewed relevant board bylaws and confirmed affirmation of legal counsel. The board discussed committee composition and committee roles, topics to be revisited during the next board meeting in July, 2023.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
John Flaherty |
Abstain
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
E.
Brown Act Training
Tom Peraic presented an annual Brown Act training. Topics included origin and context of the law; committee types; the definition of meeting and types of meetings (permitted and not permitted by law); public comments; closed sessions; and Brown Act violations and repercussions.
IV. Academic
A.
Academic Success Committee Report
Claire Grissom reviewed topics presented during the most recent meeting of the committee. These included interim Star assessment results and related considerations, including assessment windows, teacher training, and participation rates; student goals relating to instruction and intervention; chronic absenteeism; the CA School Dashboard; Navigator Schools Model dissemination; and board member school visits. Kevin Sved and John Flaherty added suggestions pertaining to the planning of school visits.
V. Topical, Part 1
A.
Resolution: CEO and Superintendent Compensation Comparability Study
Members discussed a Compensation Comparability Study (“Study”) presented by Tom Peraic, General Counsel. The Study contained appropriate data in the form of compensation levels paid by similarly situated organizations for functionally comparable positions, the availability of similar services in the geographic area of Navigator, and current compensation surveys compiled by independent firms. The Study is supported with relevant statutes and regulations.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
VI. Closed Session
A.
Announcement of Reason for Closed Session and Vote to Enter
The board chair announced the reason for the closed session, and members voted to enter closed session.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
B.
Closed Session
C.
Announcement of Action Taken During Closed Session
The board chair announced action taken by the board during closed session. By unanimous vote by all of the board members present, the board approved Caprice Young to become the Chief Executive Officer and Superintendent of Navigator Schools.
VII. Topical, Part 2
A.
Required Oral Report Regarding Employment Agreement for CEO and Superintendent
In furtherance to the announcement of action taken during closed session, the board chair reported the terms contained in the CEO and Superintendent Employment Agreement, and affirmed that those terms are wholly in keeping with the Study that the board received, reviewed, and approved.
B.
Ratification of Employment Agreement for Navigator Schools CEO and Superintendent
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
The board chair congratulated the search committee, board members, and Kevin Sved for successfully completing the candidate search and hiring process.
C.
Resolution: Separation Exemption to Provide Speech Pathology Services and Supervision
Melissa Alatorre Alnas explained the background and purpose of the resolution.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
D.
Statement of Need: California Commission on Teacher Credentialing
Melissa Alatorre Alnas shared the background and purpose of submitting a Declaration of Need For Fully Qualified Educators to the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing on behalf of each Navigator school. She explained related legislation (Assembly Bill 1505). The board voted to approve a Declaration of Need for each Navigator school: Gilroy Prep School, Hayward Collegiate, Hollister Prep School, and Watsonville Prep School.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
E.
Memorandum of Understanding with the Boys and Girls Club of Silicon Valley
Kirsten Carr reviewed the context of the memorandum and recommendations for next steps pertaining to after school programs for students at school sites.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
VIII. Consent Agenda
A.
Approval of the Consent Agenda
The board chair reviewed the contents of the Consent Agenda. He commented on the recent celebration of the Juneteenth holiday. Ami Ortiz confirmed the addition of two holidays to the academic calendar for 2023-24.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
IX. Closing Items
A.
Adjourn Meeting
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Chuck Daggs |
Aye
|
Jaime Quiroga |
Aye
|
John Flaherty |
Aye
|
JP Anderson |
Aye
|
Ian Connell |
Absent
|
Shara Hegde |
Aye
|
Victor Paredes-Colonia |
Aye
|
Claire Grissom |
Aye
|
Alfred Morikang |
Absent
|
There were no public comments.