MCCPS Board of Trustees
Minutes
Governance Monthly Meeting - May 2020
Date and Time
Tuesday May 5, 2020 at 7:00 PM
Location
Join Zoom Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84179925999?pwd=QTZSRlBhc0FteFBrek9rNkpTSVgzZz09
Meeting ID: 841 7992 5999
Password: 006377
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84179925999?pwd=QTZSRlBhc0FteFBrek9rNkpTSVgzZz09
Meeting ID: 841 7992 5999
Password: 006377
Committee Members Present
Christopher Riegle (remote), Cynthia Canavan (remote), Elizabeth Burns (remote), Jeanne Smith (remote), Karl Smith (remote), Kay O'Dwyer (remote), Paul Baker (remote), Peter Cohen (remote)
Committee Members Absent
None
Guests Present
Alf Wilson, Artie Sullivan (remote)
I. Opening Items
A.
Record Attendance
B.
Call the Meeting to Order
Karl Smith called a meeting of the Governance Committee of MCCPS Board of Trustees to order on Tuesday May 5, 2020 at 7:03 PM.
Karl Smith made a motion to Accept Governor Baker's Executive Order allowing for remote meetings. Note that in light of the ongoing COVID-19 coronavirus outbreak, Governor Baker issued an emergency Order on March 12, 2020, allowing public bodies greater flexibility in utilizing technology in the conduct of meetings under the Open Meeting Law. This committee makes a motion to accept this Executive Order for this meeting of the Governance Committee, on May 5, 2020.
Paul Baker seconded the motion.
The committee VOTED to approve the motion.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Jeanne Smith |
Aye
|
Kay O'Dwyer |
Aye
|
Paul Baker |
Aye
|
Elizabeth Burns |
Aye
|
Christopher Riegle |
Aye
|
Cynthia Canavan |
Aye
|
Karl Smith |
Aye
|
C.
Approve Minutes
Karl Smith made a motion to approve the minutes from Governance Monthly Meeting - February 2020 on 02-04-20.
Christopher Riegle seconded the motion.
The committee VOTED to approve the motion.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Jeanne Smith |
Abstain
|
Elizabeth Burns |
Aye
|
Karl Smith |
Aye
|
Cynthia Canavan |
Aye
|
Kay O'Dwyer |
Aye
|
Christopher Riegle |
Aye
|
D.
Approve Minutes
These minutes are not for the Governance Committee to approve - please disregard.
E.
Approve Minutes
Kay O'Dwyer made a motion to approve the minutes from Governance Monthly Meeting - April 2020 on 04-08-20.
Elizabeth Burns seconded the motion.
The committee VOTED to approve the motion.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Jeanne Smith |
Aye
|
Cynthia Canavan |
Aye
|
Christopher Riegle |
Aye
|
Paul Baker |
Abstain
|
Karl Smith |
Aye
|
Elizabeth Burns |
Aye
|
Kay O'Dwyer |
Aye
|
F.
Approve Minutes
Paul Baker made a motion to approve the minutes from Governance Committee By Laws Review on 04-14-20.
Karl Smith seconded the motion.
Typo - in review by-laws draft - first roll call vote - under names - motion made - its - no apostrophe (note: corrected on May 29th).
The committee VOTED to approve the motion.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Christopher Riegle |
Aye
|
Elizabeth Burns |
Aye
|
Kay O'Dwyer |
Aye
|
Jeanne Smith |
Aye
|
Karl Smith |
Aye
|
Cynthia Canavan |
Aye
|
II. Governance Matters
A.
Board Meeting Update
Paul Baker provided an update regarding the April 28th Board meeting.
He reviewed all of the key agenda items highlighting the following:
Several different ideas and topics were discussed. The potential financial impact was also noted.
He reviewed all of the key agenda items highlighting the following:
- HOS update
- Staffing updates
- Enrollment
- Remote learning
- Finance
- HOS Evaluation - BOT - ValEd
Several different ideas and topics were discussed. The potential financial impact was also noted.
B.
Board Composition
The current status of open seats and soon to be open seats were discussed in detail (see memo for specifics).
Several potential candidates were noted and discussed, including parents, teachers, committee members and future parents.
The group agreed to reach out to determine level of interest and invite the potential candidates to participate in future meetings.
Several potential candidates were noted and discussed, including parents, teachers, committee members and future parents.
The group agreed to reach out to determine level of interest and invite the potential candidates to participate in future meetings.
C.
By-Laws Update
There were some initial discussions regarding the Head of School's ability to vote on Governance matters. In the end it was clarified during out review of the by-laws that he is a non-voting member of the committee.
With regards to the school's legal counsel's review notes and feedback regarding the updated by-laws, there was much discussion.
Initial questions regarded his overall experience with school / state law and a concern was raised regarding that level of expertise given some of the comments particularly with regards to emergency meetings and community members.
Peter Cohen noted that the attorney was vetted along with a few other potential candidates and based on a listing of existing clients, he was satisfied in the overall competency of the legal team engaged.
Some discussion and review of the language involving seated / sitting members resulted in some clarified and enhanced language within the by-laws.
Next ensued a protracted discussion regarding the approach to the Chair of Governance and how it should be captured in the by-laws.
Generally speaking there are two positions being promoted, one is to maintain the existing approach where the Chair of Governance is not required to be a board member and that the Governance Committee itself determines who the chair will be versus the updated approach to align Governance with all other committees where the chair is required to be a standing member of the Board of Trustees.
Matters such as independence, reporting responsibilities, work load, functions, and other areas were covered in detail with members providing their opinions and positions.
It was agreed that this committee had fulfilled our responsibility to present the board with updated by-laws and that the final determination on how to approach the Governance Chair would rest with the board members.
Therefore the updated draft with all of the comments and recommendations would be presented along with the a summary of the different positions for their consideration.
With regards to the school's legal counsel's review notes and feedback regarding the updated by-laws, there was much discussion.
Initial questions regarded his overall experience with school / state law and a concern was raised regarding that level of expertise given some of the comments particularly with regards to emergency meetings and community members.
Peter Cohen noted that the attorney was vetted along with a few other potential candidates and based on a listing of existing clients, he was satisfied in the overall competency of the legal team engaged.
Some discussion and review of the language involving seated / sitting members resulted in some clarified and enhanced language within the by-laws.
Next ensued a protracted discussion regarding the approach to the Chair of Governance and how it should be captured in the by-laws.
Generally speaking there are two positions being promoted, one is to maintain the existing approach where the Chair of Governance is not required to be a board member and that the Governance Committee itself determines who the chair will be versus the updated approach to align Governance with all other committees where the chair is required to be a standing member of the Board of Trustees.
Matters such as independence, reporting responsibilities, work load, functions, and other areas were covered in detail with members providing their opinions and positions.
It was agreed that this committee had fulfilled our responsibility to present the board with updated by-laws and that the final determination on how to approach the Governance Chair would rest with the board members.
Therefore the updated draft with all of the comments and recommendations would be presented along with the a summary of the different positions for their consideration.
Karl Smith made a motion to Present the amended version of the by-laws as of May 5, 2020 to be presented to the Board of Trustees at the next scheduled meeting for their consideration.
Paul Baker seconded the motion.
The committee VOTED to approve the motion.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Cynthia Canavan |
Aye
|
Christopher Riegle |
Aye
|
Elizabeth Burns |
Absent
|
Jeanne Smith |
Aye
|
Karl Smith |
Aye
|
Kay O'Dwyer |
Aye
|
Paul Baker |
Aye
|
III. Other Business
A.
Planning for future meeting
First Tuesday - June 2nd - 7 PM
Summary of items to consider for next meeting:
- Board composition memo
- Proposed calendar of relevant events and initiatives for Governance
- Potential training topics for the board retreat (Board on track 'nuts and bolts', Robert's Rules, etc)
- New trustee training
Karl Smith made a motion to Adjuorn meeting.
Jeanne Smith seconded the motion.
The committee VOTED to approve the motion.
Roll Call | |
---|---|
Kay O'Dwyer |
Aye
|
Paul Baker |
Aye
|
Cynthia Canavan |
Aye
|
Jeanne Smith |
Aye
|
Karl Smith |
Aye
|
Elizabeth Burns |
Absent
|
Christopher Riegle |
Aye
|
IV. Closing Items
A.
Adjourn Meeting
There being no further business to be transacted, and upon motion duly made, seconded and approved, the meeting was adjourned at 8:30 PM.
Respectfully Submitted,
Karl Smith
Documents used during the meeting
- MCCPS Trustees Composition Report-May-2020.docx
- BYLAWS Working Copy, 2020-April 14, reviewed by counsel.docx