Da Vinci Schools
Minutes
Da Vinci Schools Board Meeting
Date and Time
Wednesday August 21, 2019 at 6:00 PM
Location
Board Room, 201 N. Douglas Street, El Segundo, CA 90245
Da Vinci Schools ("DV") welcomes your participation at its Board meetings. The purpose of a public meeting of the Board of Directors ("Board") is to conduct the affairs of DV in public. Your participation assures us of continuing community interest in our schools. To assist you in speaking/participating in our meetings, the following guidelines are provided:
- Agendas are available to all audience members at the door to the meeting.
- "Request to Speak" forms are available to all audience members who wish to speak on any agenda items or under the general category of "Public Comments," which is time set aside for members of the audience to raise issues not specifically on the agenda. However, due to public meeting laws, the Board can only listen to your issue, not respond or take action. These presentations are limited to three (3) minutes and total time allotted to non-agenda items will not exceed fifteen (15) minutes. Non-English speakers who use a translator shall have six (6) minutes in which to address the Board.
- The Board may give direction to staff to respond to your concern or you may be offered the option of returning with a citizen-requested item.
- The chair will recognize such individuals who wish to speak on a specific agenda item at the appropriate time. When addressing the Board, speakers are requested to adhere to the time limits set forth, and to not repeat remarks made by those who preceded them.
- Any public records relating to an agenda item for an open session of the Board which are distributed to all, or a majority of all, of the Board members shall be available for public inspection at 201 N. Douglas Street, El Segundo, CA 90245, during Business Office operating hours.
Trustees Present
B. Meath, D. Brann, I. Mora, J. Morgan, K. Brown, R. Bañuelos
Trustees Absent
None
Trustees who arrived after the meeting opened
B. Meath
Trustees who left before the meeting adjourned
I. Mora
Guests Present
A. Wohlwerth, B. Silvers, Bernard Bella, C. Levenson, E. D'Souza, J. Hawn, M. Rainey, M. Ring, M. Wunder, S. Wallis, V. Bravo
I. Opening Items
A.
Call the Meeting to Order
D. Brann called a meeting of the board of trustees of Da Vinci Schools to order on Wednesday Aug 21, 2019 at 6:00 PM.
B.
Record Attendance and Guests
C.
Approval of Agenda
I. Mora made a motion to amend the agenda to remove the Financial Update, due to the unaudited actual financials coming in later than anticipated.
K. Brown seconded the motion.
The board VOTED unanimously to approve the motion.
D.
Public Comments
Robert Nitsos, parent, and alumna Emma Johnson spoke on the archery program at Da Vinci Schools. Mr. Nitsos gave the context of the comments regarding changes in the archery program. Ms. Johnson, a former member of the archery program, and an archery coach, described the makeup of the archery program participants (from three Da Vinci high schools and all grade levels), and the work of various adults who support the program.
Ms. Linda Cessor read a letter from Idida Briones, head of the Olympic Archery in Schools program.
Dr. Brann and other Board members thanked the group for their comments.
Dr. Brann and other Board members thanked the group for their comments.
II. Information
A.
From the Board
Mr. Ken Brown commented on the start of school, saying that his older child had just started college and his younger child had just started at Da Vinci Schools this week.
Mr. Israel Mora welcomed staff and students back to school.
Mr. Roger Bañuelos welcomed everyone to the 2019-20 school year. He added that his third child had just started at Da Vinci Science this week and spoke of his pride in all of the Da Vinci schools and programs. He requested more information on archery funding and process from Dr. Wunder.
Dr. Brann spoke of seeing all the students arriving at school on the first day of the 11th year of Da Vinci Schools. He commended the staff and Mr. Vicente Bravo for the smoothness of the day in the face of challenging logistics.
Dr. Brann also asked for more information on the archery program, CIF sports, and facilities from the Athletic Director, and thanked the guests for their attendance and comments.
Mr. Israel Mora welcomed staff and students back to school.
Mr. Roger Bañuelos welcomed everyone to the 2019-20 school year. He added that his third child had just started at Da Vinci Science this week and spoke of his pride in all of the Da Vinci schools and programs. He requested more information on archery funding and process from Dr. Wunder.
Dr. Brann spoke of seeing all the students arriving at school on the first day of the 11th year of Da Vinci Schools. He commended the staff and Mr. Vicente Bravo for the smoothness of the day in the face of challenging logistics.
Dr. Brann also asked for more information on the archery program, CIF sports, and facilities from the Athletic Director, and thanked the guests for their attendance and comments.
B.
From the CEO
None
C.
Connect 9-12 Update
Dr. Wunder, Dr. Hawn, and Ms. Rainey gave a presentation on Da Vinci Connect.
Dr. Hawn spoke of having worked with Southern New Hampshire University (SNHU) to determine if college competencies aligned to a-g high school courses, and whether or not high school students could do the college-level work alongside high school work. The goal was to allow students to work on a two or even four year degree while in high school, and perhaps add a year or two in additional coursework. The integration of high school diploma and college degree would also allow students to avoid college debt.
Ms. Rainey spoke of focusing on real world skill sets and the need to make students employable by learning to solve problems outside of existing, predetermined solutions. At Da Vinci Extension, students work with SNHU, UCLA Extension, and El Camino College on college courses toward either an AA or BA degree (SNHU), or transferable IGETC credits (UCLA Extension, El Camino). Ms. Rainey added that the goal is to take an existing, fine-tuned, well-embraced DVX program and back it up into the high school experience.
Components of the four years would include financial literacy; soft skills; and social emotional learning.
Key elements of the program would be:
Dr. Wunder added that he thinks it is wise to put all of Da Vinci independent study in one charter petition. Dr. Hawn outlined anticipated outcomes:
1. Charter revision - December 2019
2. Successful completion of high school and college coursework - June 2020
3. Course descriptions - July 2020
4. A-G approval - February 2021
5. Happy kids pursuing their passions - now
Dr. Brann spoke of Da Vinci being on the leading edge and keeping up with the advances and deadlines. He spoke of perhaps needing a workshop to further work on the issue.
Mr. Mora asked about charter law changing in January. Dr. Wunder spoke of the two bills moving through the legislature: AB 1505 and AB 1507. One of the bills would curtail independent study schools. Dr. Brann added that the legislature is facing a September 11 deadline for these bills. Dr. Wunder spoke of needing to give the Da Vinci and Wiseburn boards more of a runway to consider the change to the charter petition. His goal is to discuss the charter changes with the Wiseburn board in early October.
Dr. Brann gave a bit of the history on the origins of Connect under the requirements of the charter laws of 2008. He advised paying close attention to the laws, which can change quickly.
Dr. Hawn spoke of having worked with Southern New Hampshire University (SNHU) to determine if college competencies aligned to a-g high school courses, and whether or not high school students could do the college-level work alongside high school work. The goal was to allow students to work on a two or even four year degree while in high school, and perhaps add a year or two in additional coursework. The integration of high school diploma and college degree would also allow students to avoid college debt.
Ms. Rainey spoke of focusing on real world skill sets and the need to make students employable by learning to solve problems outside of existing, predetermined solutions. At Da Vinci Extension, students work with SNHU, UCLA Extension, and El Camino College on college courses toward either an AA or BA degree (SNHU), or transferable IGETC credits (UCLA Extension, El Camino). Ms. Rainey added that the goal is to take an existing, fine-tuned, well-embraced DVX program and back it up into the high school experience.
Components of the four years would include financial literacy; soft skills; and social emotional learning.
Key elements of the program would be:
- Integration of High School Diploma and College Degree (Dual enrollment via SNHU, UCLA Extension, El Camino College)
- Community Relationships (Synchronous, face-to-face instruction; asynchronous, online instruction; field learning; face-to-face with Zoom support; student-led meetups)
- Employable Skill Sets (Financial literacy; internships; "soft skills"; social emotional learning)
Dr. Wunder added that he thinks it is wise to put all of Da Vinci independent study in one charter petition. Dr. Hawn outlined anticipated outcomes:
1. Charter revision - December 2019
2. Successful completion of high school and college coursework - June 2020
3. Course descriptions - July 2020
4. A-G approval - February 2021
5. Happy kids pursuing their passions - now
Dr. Brann spoke of Da Vinci being on the leading edge and keeping up with the advances and deadlines. He spoke of perhaps needing a workshop to further work on the issue.
Mr. Mora asked about charter law changing in January. Dr. Wunder spoke of the two bills moving through the legislature: AB 1505 and AB 1507. One of the bills would curtail independent study schools. Dr. Brann added that the legislature is facing a September 11 deadline for these bills. Dr. Wunder spoke of needing to give the Da Vinci and Wiseburn boards more of a runway to consider the change to the charter petition. His goal is to discuss the charter changes with the Wiseburn board in early October.
Dr. Brann gave a bit of the history on the origins of Connect under the requirements of the charter laws of 2008. He advised paying close attention to the laws, which can change quickly.
Dr. Blake Silvers commented on sending his oldest child to Da Vinci this year, and thanked the Da Vinci team for helping his family with the transition, saying that his daughter has come home everyday with a smile.
D.
Sick Leave Transfers
Dr. Wunder thanked the staff who brought up this inquiry for their professionalism, saying that they had done a lot of research. It's a complex issue, and the team wanted to discuss it with the Board.
Dr. Hawn commented that legal counsel was consulted, due to the equity impact. Employee leaves are complicated. Catastrophic leave has clear boundaries and criteria defined by Ed Code. It is optional for charter schools. A new process/system would have to be created for the requested type of sick leave transfer; catastrophic leave protocol cannot be used.
Mr. Mora asked about next steps. Dr. Hawn spoke of this being a policy change.
Mr. Brown asked about financial costs. Dr. Hawn responded that there could be additional costs (such as hiring substitute teachers, and more use of sick days as trades occur).
Dr. Brann asked for more work on the issue.
Ms. Morgan clarified that this is an equity issue, and that she sees both sides. In her opinion, much as she would want to say yes, it would be really difficult to do.
Mr. Bañuelos clarified that it is banked sick leave that is being considered for transfer. He asked whether the maternity leave days that a mother doesn't take would be able to be transferred to someone else. Dr. Hawn responded that under the law, 17 weeks of maternity leave is allowed, but within that time frame, once banked sick leave has been used up, any remaining time taken is unpaid.
Dr. Brann mentioned that for certificated staff, the unused sick leave has value at retirement, as it can be credited as time worked.
Mr. Mora would consider it, saying that there wouldn't be many cases/requests, and the flexibility is desirable to employees.
Ms. Morgan pointed out that if the rule is created, more requests may appear, and the work must still be done by someone.
Dr. Brann agrees with Mr. Mora that this issue should be studied further.
Mr. Brown is in favor of looking into it further, and at creating a process where equity and financial impact are considered.
Dr. Brann spoke of needing to set up a catastrophic leave bank at Da Vinci Schools.
Mr. Meath would also like to study it further, adding that legal counsel should be consulted, and certificated employees should acknowledge in writing that they are giving up the future value of the sick leave.
Dr. Hawn commented that legal counsel was consulted, due to the equity impact. Employee leaves are complicated. Catastrophic leave has clear boundaries and criteria defined by Ed Code. It is optional for charter schools. A new process/system would have to be created for the requested type of sick leave transfer; catastrophic leave protocol cannot be used.
Mr. Mora asked about next steps. Dr. Hawn spoke of this being a policy change.
Mr. Brown asked about financial costs. Dr. Hawn responded that there could be additional costs (such as hiring substitute teachers, and more use of sick days as trades occur).
Dr. Brann asked for more work on the issue.
Ms. Morgan clarified that this is an equity issue, and that she sees both sides. In her opinion, much as she would want to say yes, it would be really difficult to do.
Mr. Bañuelos clarified that it is banked sick leave that is being considered for transfer. He asked whether the maternity leave days that a mother doesn't take would be able to be transferred to someone else. Dr. Hawn responded that under the law, 17 weeks of maternity leave is allowed, but within that time frame, once banked sick leave has been used up, any remaining time taken is unpaid.
Dr. Brann mentioned that for certificated staff, the unused sick leave has value at retirement, as it can be credited as time worked.
Mr. Mora would consider it, saying that there wouldn't be many cases/requests, and the flexibility is desirable to employees.
Ms. Morgan pointed out that if the rule is created, more requests may appear, and the work must still be done by someone.
Dr. Brann agrees with Mr. Mora that this issue should be studied further.
Mr. Brown is in favor of looking into it further, and at creating a process where equity and financial impact are considered.
Dr. Brann spoke of needing to set up a catastrophic leave bank at Da Vinci Schools.
Mr. Meath would also like to study it further, adding that legal counsel should be consulted, and certificated employees should acknowledge in writing that they are giving up the future value of the sick leave.
B. Meath arrived.
E.
Facilities Update
1:11:10 on tape
Mr. Bravo gave a brief update.
Bungalows are set up at the Del Aire site.
Fire alarms will be installed in all restrooms there.
Plumbing and flooring are being worked on at the present time.
The non-functioning air conditioning in the front office must be replaced.
The Da Vinci Extension move to the Continental site has been successful. The parking issue has been amicably resolved. The student body was given options (parking at the Aviation site and using TAP cards for transportation to the new site, etc.).
Mr. Bravo described the process of researching security companies, after Da Vinci parted ways with its former security company. He is presenting two companies for the Board's review. He is also looking at an internal security team, at less cost and greater continuity.
Mr. Mora asked about the amount budgeted for this expense. The Campus Security Officers (CSOs) are still on campus. A new officer, Stephanie Martinez, has joined the team. Dr. Brann thanked Chief Whalen for placing the CSOs on campus. Dr. Brann also thanked Mr. Bravo for the smooth flow of traffic on the first day of school.
Mr. Brann clarified that the CSOs' work has been augmented by staff and administration.
Mr. Mora spoke of his concern that it will be difficult to find the right people for the pay.
Ms. Morgan commented on the rationale for not retaining the security company.
Discussion about the CSO's stopping drivers who are committing unsafe maneuvers ensued.
Mr. Bravo gave a brief update.
Bungalows are set up at the Del Aire site.
Fire alarms will be installed in all restrooms there.
Plumbing and flooring are being worked on at the present time.
The non-functioning air conditioning in the front office must be replaced.
The Da Vinci Extension move to the Continental site has been successful. The parking issue has been amicably resolved. The student body was given options (parking at the Aviation site and using TAP cards for transportation to the new site, etc.).
Mr. Bravo described the process of researching security companies, after Da Vinci parted ways with its former security company. He is presenting two companies for the Board's review. He is also looking at an internal security team, at less cost and greater continuity.
Mr. Mora asked about the amount budgeted for this expense. The Campus Security Officers (CSOs) are still on campus. A new officer, Stephanie Martinez, has joined the team. Dr. Brann thanked Chief Whalen for placing the CSOs on campus. Dr. Brann also thanked Mr. Bravo for the smooth flow of traffic on the first day of school.
Mr. Brann clarified that the CSOs' work has been augmented by staff and administration.
Mr. Mora spoke of his concern that it will be difficult to find the right people for the pay.
Ms. Morgan commented on the rationale for not retaining the security company.
Discussion about the CSO's stopping drivers who are committing unsafe maneuvers ensued.
F.
Financial Update
This item was removed, as the books are not ready to be closed.
In lieu of the Financial Update, Dr. Brann requested a brief discussion on the enrollment update prepared by Carla Levenson.
Brief discussion on enrollment ensued.
Ms. Levenson spoke of over-enrolling with an eye toward attrition. There are currently 825 on the waitlist for grades 9 through 12.
Mr. Brown asked about percentages of enrollment acceptance - how many students who are accepted actually attend?
Ms. Levenson spoke of 88-89% of Dana graduates who enroll at Da Vinci, and the 80% of Connect graduates who enroll at Da Vinci high schools.
Discussion on preferences and Wiseburn residency ensued.
Ms. Levenson also spoke of the very few enrollment issues this school year.
Brief discussion on enrollment ensued.
Ms. Levenson spoke of over-enrolling with an eye toward attrition. There are currently 825 on the waitlist for grades 9 through 12.
Mr. Brown asked about percentages of enrollment acceptance - how many students who are accepted actually attend?
Ms. Levenson spoke of 88-89% of Dana graduates who enroll at Da Vinci, and the 80% of Connect graduates who enroll at Da Vinci high schools.
Discussion on preferences and Wiseburn residency ensued.
Ms. Levenson also spoke of the very few enrollment issues this school year.
III. Approval of Minutes
A.
Approve Minutes of the July 25, 2019 Regular Board Meeting
I. Mora made a motion to approve minutes from the Da Vinci Schools Board Meeting on 07-25-19 Da Vinci Schools Board Meeting on 07-25-19.
R. Bañuelos seconded the motion.
The board VOTED unanimously to approve the motion.
B.
Approve Minutes of the Joint Wiseburn + Da Vinci Board Meeting
I. Mora made a motion to approve minutes from the Wiseburn + Da Vinci Joint Board Meeting on 06-08-19 Wiseburn + Da Vinci Joint Board Meeting on 06-08-19.
R. Bañuelos seconded the motion.
The board VOTED unanimously to approve the motion.
IV. New Board Member
A.
Nomination of New Da Vinci Schools Board of Trustees Member
Ms. Morgan and Mr. Meath both spoke to the nominee, and approve.
Mr. Brown spoke with some of the nominee's peers.
Dr. Brann spoke to one of the nominee's PLTW peers as well as to the nominee.
The nominee told Dr. Brann that Da Vinci Schools have served her children well.
Mr. Mora thanked Dr. Brann for all of his time. He would like the Board to consider interviewing the top two or three candidates. Dr. Brann responded that this was a more formal process than that used for Mr. Brown, but that it is essentially the same process.
Ms. Morgan expressed her own thoughts that there would be three candidates. Mr. Bañuelos would like to interview the top three candidates, acknowledging that he was not available earlier to do so.
Mr. Meath clarified that the Board would like Dr. Brann to afford the top three candidates the chance to interview with the full Board.
The Board expressed the desire to individually speak to the other candidates.
For future process, Mr. Mora would like a minimum of three on the subcommittee, and the committee may be made up of more than Board members.
Further discussion ensued; Dr. Brann proposed taking the next month to allow the Board to meet with the top three candidates. He will send his findings to the Board.
Mr. Brown spoke with some of the nominee's peers.
Dr. Brann spoke to one of the nominee's PLTW peers as well as to the nominee.
The nominee told Dr. Brann that Da Vinci Schools have served her children well.
Mr. Mora thanked Dr. Brann for all of his time. He would like the Board to consider interviewing the top two or three candidates. Dr. Brann responded that this was a more formal process than that used for Mr. Brown, but that it is essentially the same process.
Ms. Morgan expressed her own thoughts that there would be three candidates. Mr. Bañuelos would like to interview the top three candidates, acknowledging that he was not available earlier to do so.
Mr. Meath clarified that the Board would like Dr. Brann to afford the top three candidates the chance to interview with the full Board.
The Board expressed the desire to individually speak to the other candidates.
For future process, Mr. Mora would like a minimum of three on the subcommittee, and the committee may be made up of more than Board members.
Further discussion ensued; Dr. Brann proposed taking the next month to allow the Board to meet with the top three candidates. He will send his findings to the Board.
V. Consent Agenda
A.
Approve Check Register - July 2019
K. Brown made a motion to approve.
B. Meath seconded the motion.
The board VOTED unanimously to approve the motion.
B.
Approve 2019-20 College and Career Access Pathways (CCAP) Partnership Agreement - El Camino College
Mr. Brown spoke of the CCAP agreement having been approved at the El Camino College's Board meeting earlier in the week. El Camino College would like to expand the partnership with DV.
Legal counsel will be consulted regarding Mr. Brown's possible conflict of interest.
Legal counsel will be consulted regarding Mr. Brown's possible conflict of interest.
I. Mora made a motion to approve the 2019-20 College and Career Access Pathways (CCAP) agreement with El Camino College.
R. Bañuelos seconded the motion.
The board VOTED unanimously to approve the motion.
C.
Approve Revised Personnel Contracts
This item was pulled for further discussion.
R. Bañuelos made a motion to approve.
K. Brown seconded the motion.
The board VOTED unanimously to approve the motion.
D.
Approve 2019-2020 Master Contract with Beach Cities Learning Center
K. Brown made a motion to approve the Master Contract with Beach Cities Learning Center.
B. Meath seconded the motion.
The board VOTED unanimously to approve the motion.
E.
Approve Master Contract with Beacon Day School (NPS)
K. Brown made a motion to approve the Master Contract with Beacon Day School.
B. Meath seconded the motion.
The board VOTED unanimously to approve the motion.
F.
Approve 2019-20 Student and Family Handbooks
K. Brown made a motion to approve the 2019-20 Student and Family Handbooks for Da Vinci Connect, Da Vinci Communications, Da Vinci Design, and Da Vinci Science.
B. Meath seconded the motion.
The board VOTED unanimously to approve the motion.
VI. Closed Session
A.
Conference with Legal Counsel
Entered at 8:09 p.m.
B.
Public Employee Performance Evaluation
VII. Closing Items
A.
Reconvene for Public Session & Closed Session Reporting
Open Session reconvened at 9:57 p.m.
Dr. Brann asked for a motion on Item C.
Mr. Banuelos moved to approve Item C.; Mr. Brown seconded.
Vote was unanimous
Aye 6
Nay 0
Dr. Brann asked for a motion on Item C.
Mr. Banuelos moved to approve Item C.; Mr. Brown seconded.
Vote was unanimous
Aye 6
Nay 0
I. Mora left.
B.
Adjourn Meeting
K. Brown made a motion to adjourn the meeting.
J. Morgan seconded the motion.
The board VOTED unanimously to approve the motion.
There being no further business to be transacted, and upon motion duly made, seconded and approved, the meeting was adjourned at 10:14 PM.
Respectfully Submitted,
A. Wohlwerth
Sarah Nitsos read from an essay that her son wrote during his 9th grade year at Da Vinci Science on the impact of archery on his life.