Magnolia Public Schools

Minutes

Regular Board Meeting

Date and Time

Thursday May 18, 2023 at 6:00 PM

Location

Magnolia Science Academy -1: 18238 Sherman Way, Reseda, CA 91335

Board Members:
Mr. Mekan Muhammedov, Chair

Ms. Sandra Covarrubias, Vice-Chair

Dr. Umit Yapanel
Dr. Salih Dikbas
Ms. Diane Gonzalez

Mr. Daniel Sheehan

Mrs. Esra Eldem Tunc

CEO & Superintendent:
Mr. Alfredo Rubalcava

Directors Present

D. Gonzalez, D. Sheehan (remote), E. Eldem Tunc, M. Muhammedov, S. Covarrubias, S. Dikbas (remote), U. Yapanel

Directors Absent

None

Directors who arrived after the meeting opened

D. Sheehan, M. Muhammedov

Directors who left before the meeting adjourned

U. Yapanel

I. Opening Items

A.

Call the Meeting to Order

S. Covarrubias called a meeting of the board of directors of Magnolia Public Schools to order on Thursday May 18, 2023 at 6:26 PM.

B.

Pledge of Allegiance

Meeting participants and guests did the pledge of allegiance.

C.

Record Attendance and Guests

Refer to attendance information recorded above.

D.

Approval of Agenda

U. Yapanel made a motion to approve the amended agenda with the removal of Action Item IV B.
D. Gonzalez seconded the motion.

A.Rubalcava, CEO & Superintendent, reported out the removal of the agenda item.

The board VOTED to approve the motion.
Roll Call
S. Dikbas
Aye
M. Muhammedov
Absent
D. Sheehan
Absent
S. Covarrubias
Aye
D. Gonzalez
Aye
E. Eldem Tunc
Aye
U. Yapanel
Aye

E.

Public Comments

Hugo Hernandez, community member, commented that he is a parent of two children who attended charter schools clarifying that they did not attend a MPS school. He commented on the importance of education in charter schools and shared that he leads the effort to ensure parent engagement becomes a central focus in charter systems. He commended MPS in the efforts of communicating Board meetings to parents and posting them at all schools. He added that the process of signing up to make a public comment and the website were easy to view and follow. He expressed to continue the efforts to expand parent roles and spoke about the struggles parents face. 

Caitlin Wright, MSA-San Diego teacher, addressed certain concerns to the current grading system. The system was to aid students during the pandemic, and shared that now that students are back in the classrooms, changes to that policy should be made to hold students accountable. 

Kim Geiger, MSA-1 teacher, also addressed the grading system at her school sharing the same sentiment.

The Board addressed the public commenters that they will take feedback and instruct staff to follow-up with these concerns made.

F.

Approval of Minutes from MPS Regular Board Meeting - April 13, 2023

D. Gonzalez made a motion to approve the minutes from Regular Board Meeting on 04-13-23.
U. Yapanel seconded the motion.
The board VOTED to approve the motion.
Roll Call
U. Yapanel
Aye
M. Muhammedov
Absent
S. Covarrubias
Aye
S. Dikbas
Aye
E. Eldem Tunc
Aye
D. Sheehan
Absent
D. Gonzalez
Aye

II. Consent Items

A.

Approval of Teaching MOU Renewal Between California State University Dominguez Hills & Magnolia Public Schools

U. Yapanel made a motion to approve the renewal agreement between Magnolia Public Schools (MPS) & California State University Dominguez Hills (CSUDH) for the term 2023-2026.
S. Covarrubias seconded the motion.
The board VOTED to approve the motion.
Roll Call
S. Covarrubias
Aye
U. Yapanel
Aye
D. Gonzalez
Aye
M. Muhammedov
Absent
E. Eldem Tunc
Aye
D. Sheehan
Absent
S. Dikbas
Aye

B.

Approval of CTC Form CL-500 Declaration of Need (Emergency Permits)

D. Gonzalez made a motion to approve the Commission on Teaching Credential (“CTC”) Form CL-500 Declaration of Need for all Magnolia Public Schools (Magnolia Science Academy-1 through 8, Santa Ana, and San Diego) for the 2023-24 school year.
E. Eldem Tunc seconded the motion.
The board VOTED to approve the motion.
Roll Call
U. Yapanel
Aye
D. Gonzalez
Aye
D. Sheehan
Absent
E. Eldem Tunc
Aye
M. Muhammedov
Absent
S. Dikbas
Aye
S. Covarrubias
Aye

III. Information/Discussion Items

A.

Elections for Student Board Member

M. Muhammedov arrived at 6:57 PM.

Student finalists for the Student Board Member position gave a presentation to the Board & public for their interest in the position for 2023-2024 school year. The students from MSA-1, MSA-2, MSA-5, and MSA-Santa Ana were chosen as the finalists through school elections held where they received the majority vote from their student peers. Students were asked questions from the Board. The students will join the June 8th Regular Board Meeting to announce who the selected Student Board Member is. 

B.

Magnolia Public Schools Community Schools Initiative: Authentic Community Engagement

D. Sheehan arrived at 7:39 PM.

B.Lopez, Chief External Officer, shared information regarding the community schools initiative that started this school year. She stated the three main values are; Connection, Excellence & Innovation with the main pillar being Connection with families. In 2021, a $3 billion dollar investment by state of California went to creating more community schools. In 2022, MPS applied for nine out of the ten schools to be awarded the planning grant, which came to $1.8 million for the schools to start the work. In 2023, MSA-San Diego become 10th school to be awarded the planning grant. She announced that the State Board of Education approved eight of the schools to be awarded almost $10 million for implementation grants. She gave the floor to the parents, students and Community Schools Coordinators that were present in person and through zoom to share their testimony and the impact from this initiative.

C.

Grows, Glows & Priorities Presentations

MSA-Santa Ana & MSA-San Diego gave their glows, grows and priorities presentations for their school sites. Board questions were addressed by staff.

D.

Glows, Grows and Priorities Update

M.Avsar, Principal at MSA-4, provided an update about their enrollment and efforts to reach their goals since they last presented their Glows, Grows & Priorities. Over the course of this time, MSA-4 staff reached out to their current families and students for feedback in improving the school's programs. They completed a number of home visits and through those visits they received a few enrollments from other family members interested. He mentioned that they held an Open House on May 6th and plan to hold another on May 27th. Out of the 30+ new enrollments some were middle school grade and others for high school grade. He added that their school met with the Academic Department and other Home Office staff to open the door to enroll middle school students. He shared that the enrollment trajectory for this school is going well and are aiming to hit above their enrollment projection with more work and outreach. Additionally, MSA-4 was featured in the news in which they received interests from other parents wanting to enroll their child. A.Rubalcava, CEO & Superintendent, added feedback received from the Educational Partner survey in which parents indicated the distance of where the school is now and space issues. He further added that M.Avsar & E.Veloz, are strong MSA-4 administrators and with the assistance of the Home Office will manage to meet the demands from their parents. He provided updates regarding possible new locations for the school, but will know more towards the end of this year. Board Members questions were addressed by staff and will await for more updates.

E.

403b & 457 Plans for MPS Wide Implementation

S.Budhraja, Chief Financial Officer, presented along with Joe Faye Sr. from Allied Wealth Partners. Currently, MPS has a 401k plan, limited to a select employees. The ask was made to look at other options that would aim to support all MPS employees. They looked at a 403b plan along with a 457 plan. This presentation is aimed to inform of the plan to look at alternative retirement plan options to benefit all employees and this item will come to the Board again with more information and updates. Joe Faye Sr. defined 403b and 457 plans and explained MPS current plan and its limitations. Board questions were addressed by staff and by Joe Faye Sr. Staff will bring back further analysis given the Boards asks for more information and estimates. 

F.

ClassWallet Tool Implementation to Improve Organizational Needs

S.Budhraja, Chief Financial Officer, introduced ClassWallet tool which came after conversations and feedback received from school site principals about procurements and the delay in getting items approved and purchased for their schools and other challenges they face. Finance Department looked for a solution which S.Budhraja presented the ClassWallet tool app. He added that this application is used by other schools and entities. It allows principals to have $1,000 to make school purchases with ease and ensuring that all purchases are backed with a paper trail to ensure there is back up for audits. The Finance Departments will view everything in real time and is easily viewed for Finance Department to flag any inaccuracies or issues. Board Members questions were addressed by staff.

IV. Action Items

A.

Approval of 2023-24 School Calendars for all Magnolia Public Schools

D.Yilmaz, Chief Accountability Officer, presented the school calendars for the 2023-24 school year. He went over the analysis to ensure the instructional minutes requirement. Staff developed the calendars in collaboration with the school leadership teams who have sought feedback from their educational partners. They also looked at LAUSD, SDUSD, and SAUSD calendars and were carefully considered while finalizing the calendars. Public comments made and Board members questions were addressed by staff. Staff will look into their communication timeline to ensure teachers are informed.

U. Yapanel made a motion to approve the 2023-24 School Calendars for all Magnolia Public Schools (MPS).
D. Gonzalez seconded the motion.
The board VOTED unanimously to approve the motion.
Roll Call
S. Covarrubias
Aye
D. Gonzalez
Aye
U. Yapanel
Aye
D. Sheehan
Aye
S. Dikbas
Aye
E. Eldem Tunc
Aye
M. Muhammedov
Aye
U. Yapanel left at 9:41 PM.

B.

Approval of Resolution Empowering MPS CEO & Superintendent to Make Necessary Moves for Staffing and Organizational Changes

Item was removed during the approval of agenda.

C.

Approval of Award of Contract for Asbestos and Lead Based Paint Abatement and Demolition at 7111 Winnetka Ave.

M.Muhammedov, Board Chair & Chair of the Audit & Facilities Committee, reported out of the Committee's discussion for this item in which the Committee approved for their recommended approval to the full Board. He added that the same contractor worked on a similar project for MSA-1. M.Sahin, Project Manager, added further information about the proposals received and that this location is the property for MSA-5. P.Ontiveros, General Counsel & Director of Facilities, added that their intent is to get a jumpstart on the demolition process by doing their due diligence and moving forward with the process.

M. Muhammedov made a motion to approve the award of a contract for (1) asbestos and lead based paint abatement and (2) site demolition for the Magnolia Science Academy—5 (“MSA-5”) new Construction Project at 7111 Winnetka Street to Interior Demolition (together, the “Project”) for a total fee of $309,424.22 ($229,954.22 for demolition and $79,470.00 for asbestos abatement) and further approve that staff be authorized to negotiate and sign a professional services contract for said services in such form as staff may deem appropriate and in the best interests of Magnolia Public Schools.
D. Gonzalez seconded the motion.
The board VOTED to approve the motion.
Roll Call
S. Dikbas
Aye
U. Yapanel
Absent
D. Gonzalez
Aye
M. Muhammedov
Aye
S. Covarrubias
Aye
E. Eldem Tunc
Aye
D. Sheehan
Aye

D.

Approval of Acceptance of Title Transfer to 7111 Winnetka Ave from MPM Sherman Winnetka LLC

M.Muhammedov reported out of the Committee's discussion for this item in which the Committee approved for their recommended approval to the full Board. He added context regarding the purchasing of this the facility for MSA-5. P.Ontiveros, General Counsel & Director of Facilities, added that MPS was given an award by the Office of Public School Construction to purchase the property to build a campus. He added that to use those funds the appropriate entity would need to hold title in which title is held by LLC. That title would need to be transferred to Magnolia in order to move forward with the asbestos abatement and demolition to ensure those expenses are eligible expenses under the award. 

D. Gonzalez made a motion to approve the purchase by Magnolia Public Schools of title to the property located at 7111 Winnetka Ave (the “Property”) from MPM Sherman Winnetka LLC (“MPM LLC”) for the benefit of Magnolia Science Academy-5 (“MSA- 5”) using the proceeds from MSA-5’s award under the Charter School Facilities Program upon receipt of the advanced release of site acquisition funds.
M. Muhammedov seconded the motion.
The board VOTED to approve the motion.
Roll Call
U. Yapanel
Absent
D. Gonzalez
Aye
M. Muhammedov
Aye
S. Dikbas
Aye
S. Covarrubias
Aye
E. Eldem Tunc
Aye
D. Sheehan
Aye

V. Closed Session

A.

Public Announcement of Closed Session

M.Muahmmedov announced that the Board will be going into closed session to discuss Public Employee Performance Evaluation for the CEO & Superintendent and would report out in any actions that may be taken.

B.

Public Employee Performance Evaluation (§ 54957) - Title: CEO & Superintendent

This item was discussed in Closed Session.

C.

Report Out of Closed Session

M.Muhammedov announced in Open Session at 11:59pm that the Board discussed this matter.

VI. Closing Items

A.

Adjourn Meeting

There being no further business to be transacted, and upon motion duly made, seconded and approved, the meeting was adjourned at 12:00 AM.

Respectfully Submitted,
M. Muhammedov