State Charter Schools Commission of Georgia
Minutes
Governance & Policy Retreat
Date and Time
Friday August 9, 2024 at 9:30 AM
Location
Amicalola Falls State Park & Lodge
418 Amicalola Falls Road
Dawsonville, Georgia 30534
Amicalola Falls State Park & Lodge
418 Amicalola Falls Road
Dawsonville, GA 30534
Directors Present
B. Brockway, B. Scafidi, C. Good, L. Millan (remote), M. Dudgeon
Directors Absent
J. Cole, T. Lowden
Directors who arrived after the meeting opened
B. Scafidi, L. Millan
Directors who left before the meeting adjourned
C. Good
Guests Present
A. Mueller, C. Lockett, Carmen Freemire, D. Head, E. Wright, K. Easterbrook, K. Manthey, Michele Neely, T. Leach
I. Opening Items
A.
Record Attendance
B.
Call the Meeting to Order
II. Welcome
A.
Enhancing SCSC Support Programs
III. SCSC Re-organization Goals and Priorities
A.
Overview of Organizational Changes
The Executive Director, Chief Operating Officer, and Director of Finance discussed the staff's approach to the SCSC reorganization.
B.
Integration of New Functions
The Senior Director for the Office of Charter School Compliance and Senior Director for School Support and Outreach (effective October 1, 2024) discussed how the functions of these divisions will integrate into the SCSC's reorganized structure.
C.
Commissioner Discussion
The SCSC Chairman led a discussion about the SCSC's priorities and enhancing the services and support the SCSC provides to charter schools.
IV. Operational Monitoring
A.
Monitoring Overview
The SCSC's Senior Associate General Counsel and General Counsel presented an overview of the SCSC's operations monitoring practices, operational performance standards, and historical school performance. Staff and commissioners brainstormed ways to ensure that operations monitoring captures what is intended and is a useful tool for monitoring the operational health of state charter schools.
V. Academic Accountability
A.
Comprehensive Performance Framework (CPF) - Academic Standards
The SCSC Director of Research & Evaluation proposed updates to the Comprehensive Performance Framework (CPF) academic standards and renewal guidelines. Commissioners asked clarifying questions on the recommendations. Staff will finalize initial recommendations for discussion during the regularly scheduled August meeting.
B.
Renewal Guidelines
The Director of Research & Evaluation proposed updated renewal guidelines. Commissioners asked clarifying questions on the recommendations. Staff will finalize initial recommendations for discussion during the regularly scheduled August meeting.
VI. Charter Petitions
A.
Petition Recommendations for FY25
The General Counsel and Director of Charter Development discussed recommendations for FY25 petition priorities and clarified petition processing procedures. Commissioners asked clarifying questions about the recommendations. Staff will take commissioners' feedback and develop recommendations to present during a regularly scheduled SCSC meeting.
VII. Concluding Remarks & Recess
A.
Opportunities for Collaboration
The Executive Director discussed opportunities to strengthen the charter school landscape through collaboration with the Office of Charter School Compliance. The Senior Director for the Office of Charter School Compliance shared specifics about local authorizing dynamics, and the commissioners and staff shared general ideas on optimizing the SCSC's reorganization to achieve its objectives.
The Chairman encouraged staff to continue to think of ways to promote school success.
VIII. Return from Recess (9:15 AM, August 10, 2024)
A.
Recap of Day 1.
The Executive Director reviewed the discussions from Day 1. The Chairman made additional recommendations on updating the petition evaluation process.
IX. School Closures
A.
Closure Process
The Director of Charter Development provided an overview of closure requirements. She discussed challenges from the recent school closures, including transition plans, school records, website requirements, stakeholder notices, and surety bonds. Commissioners and staff discussed ways to address the challenges and lessons learned from recent school closures.
X. SCSC Rule & Policy Items
A.
House Bill 409
The General Counsel reviewed House Bill 409, which permits Education Service Providers (ESP) to employ teachers and other instructional faculty and staff at charter schools. Commissioners and staff discussed the need to adjust SCSC practices given the new legislation.
B.
Alternative Petition Processes
The Chairman directed staff to develop a targeted petition process to encourage petitions from high-quality existing operators and to evaluate scaling capacity.
C.
Governance Training Requirements
The staff discussed developing a policy that clarifies training standards for state charter school governing boards. Staff and commissioners discussed separate requirements for new and existing board members.
Commissioners directed staff to develop a recommendation for training requirements to ensure new boards are informed of their obligations, reduce redundancy for tenured board members, provide updates on requirements annually, and align the proposed changes with the relevant statutes.
XI. Board Relations Items
A.
Communications
The Executive Director reviewed the process for exchanging information between staff and commissioners and sought recommendations on any changes or updates.
B.
FY25 Meeting Calendar
The Executive Director sought feedback on the meeting calendar for 2025. Commissioners discussed ensuring enough meetings to cover petitions pending local denial decisions. Additional important dates were highlighted, such as petition capacity interviews, conference dates, and renewal and new school visits.
C.
Renewal School Visit
The Director of Research & Evaluation sought scheduling availability from commissioners for renewal school visits.
The Chairman welcomed staff and commissioners and encouraged the group to identify ways to supplement the SCSC's compliance functions with support to encourage school success. The Executive Director acknowledged the contributions of SCSC staff in organizing the retreat and assisting in the SCSC's reorganization strategy.